Rochester, Monroe, NY
Union & Advertiser
Wed Feb 1, 1888
 
AN AWFUL DEED
 
John Cullen Kills His Aged Mother With an Axe and Boasts of His Deed
Smashing Her Skull and Then Kissing Her Dead Face Good-Bye
Blood Found on His Moustache, Lips and Hands When Arrested
 
    Buffalo, Feb. 1 - A fair-faced man clad in a blouse, checked calico shirt, brown trousers, and wearing low-cut shoes, entered the saloon of Edward CONNORS last night, and after drinking a glass of beer turned around and said to the group:
    "I just killed my mother. Yes; it is a fact. Pat MORRISSEY killed his with a knife, but I killed mine with an axe. I smashed her brains brown, I tell you."
    The man was John CULLEN, a shipcaulker residing at 234 West Genesee street. No one believed his story as it was evident he had been drinking. He was allowed to depart, and he went to another saloon, just back of the police station, and was about to drink a glass of beer when Francis E. DeFOREST, the deputy sheriff, arrested him and took him to the stationhouse. Here he made more of a statement.
    "I killed her with an axe," he said, "and I struck her twice in the head. After she fell dead I bent over and kissed her twice."
    There was blood on the man's moustache, his cheeks, lips, shirt and hands, which confirmed the statement. He was under the influence of liquor and Capt. KILROY locked him up.
    Investigation showed that the man's story was true, and one of the most horrible murders ever committed was that of Mrs. Ann CULLEN at 234 West Genesee street, between 8 and 8:30 o'clock last night. The CULLENS lived on the second floor, and the family consisted of the mother, the son John, and her daughter, Margaret, aged 30. The front room was used as a kitchen and a bed-room, and a narrow hall led back to a large room used for drying clothes. In the hallway was the body. The woman was lying with her hands folded across her breast, and the two plain gold rings shone on the third finger. Her head was lying in a pool of blood which was spattered about the room and had covered her dress and face and hands. In the back of the left side of the head were two horrible gashes, and the brains were oozing through: Pieces of the broken skull could be seen protruding. The face showed but little evidence of suffering, and death must have been instantaneous. The sight was a ghastly one, and the only way of entering the front room was by stepping over the body.
    The front room was in disorder. Clothes were pitched about, and on the table were portions of the supper which she had started to prepare. Meat was in the frying pan on the stove, and the woman had evidently been engaged in preparing the evening meal. Behind the door of the back room was found the axe with which he committed the murder. It is an old, ordinary axe, rusty and dull, with a short handle. It had evidently been used to split kindling-wood. In the front room was a large pan filled with bloody water, in which CULLEN had evidently washed his hands.
    The first one to enter the room after the murder was the daughter Margaret. She returned from work about 8:40, and on entering saw her mother lying on the floor. She attempted to arouse her and saw that the woman was dead. She screamed and sent a little girl who was with her for Dr. Charles STEELE. He came and saw that there was nothing for him to do. Officer John O'BRIEN was notified and the patrol wagon was at once sent to the house. The police took possession of the place.
    Coroner KENNEY came, took charge of the body and had it removed to an undertaking room.
    After committing the crime CULLEN proceeded to take in all the saloons on the Terrace. In each of them he made the assertion that he had killed his mother, but no one paid any attention to his remarks. In one place he said.
    "Mother and I quarrelled and she called me a ____ and I would not stand any such talk. I smashed her head in with an axe. I did it brown."
    He repeated his statement about killing his mother and kissing her after she was dead. He added:
    "She was getting old and could not work much longer. She must starve or go to the poorhouse, and I killed her. It was the best thing to do."
    Back of the CULLENS lives the family of George RIFFLE. He is deaf and dumb, as is his wife. They have a boarder, Mason HILL, and he is also a deaf mute. The son, Geo. RIFFLE, said that his parents knew nothing about the affair. The CULLENS came to the house about two months ago and he knew nothing of them.
    Margaret stated that while she was in the room John came in and took one look at the body. She spoke to him, but he made no answer, and turned and went away.
    Mrs. Ann CULLEN was an industrious woman and, when well enough to work took in washing. All the neighbors spoke well of her. She was of medium height, quite fleshy, had dark hair, which in the dim light in the room, showed no traces of gray. She wore an alpaca waist, a gray balmoral skirt and black woolen stockings. One of her shoes was off. She had on also a checked apron. Her daughter Margaret works about the Chapin block. She left the house about 4 o'clock to go to work. During the afternoon, according to her statement, her brother came home and said that he could not work that afternoon. He laid down on the lounge and went to sleep. At 3 o'clock he got up and built the fire and went out. This was the last time she saw him before the murder.
    None of the neighbors would say that there had been any quarrels between the mother and son, and Margaret says that when she last saw them there was no ill-feeling.
    Capt. KILROY made no attempt to get any statement from CULLEN during the fore part of the evening. CULLEN was put in a cell and a watch set over him. Knowing that the captain would not be willing to have the prisoner interviewed, the reporter asked to see the man, which request was readily granted. CULLEN was standing in his cell, wearing only his shirt and trousers. He came forward and grasped the grating. The man is not vicious in his appearance, and is the last person a stranger would take for a murderer. He is of medium height with a frank, open face, light flaxen hair, a fair complexion, blue eyes, and wears a light moustache. There was a marked resemblance between him and his mother. When the captain approached he was singing in a maudlin manner, the last line of the song being "They laid her away in the cold, cold ground." He insisted on shaking hands with the captain, and the blood stains on his wristbands were very plain.
    "Captain," he said, "send for Dr. DYE and he will make things all right. Oh, I know you and I have known you a long, long time."
    "Keep quiet, keep quiet," said the captain; "you must not make so much noise," and the captain led the way out.
    The stories about CULLEN are very contradictory." Some say that he was crazy when drunk, while others assert that he was a simple fellow, who never would quarrel. All agree that he was a chronic drunkard. He had many odd traits of character.
    Mrs. CULLEN's husband was killed in the late war. She was very kind to her son, according to those who knew the family.
----<>----
HORRIBLE CONFESSION
 
Young Robinski Tells How He Murdered Thomas Majka
    Saratoga, N. Y., Feb. 1 - The plea of murder in the second degree put in by ROBINSKI, whose trial for the killing of Thomas MAJKA has resulted in a disagreement of the jury, was accepted, and the prisoner sentenced to the State's prison at Dannemora for life. He did not seem to mind his sentence. One of his interpreters said afterward that when he was told that he would not be hung if he pleaded guilty to murder in the second degree he said that was all that he cared for, because if he went to prison he would certainly have all that he wanted to eat, and that was more than he had many times before he was put in jail. After his sentence he made a confession, saying that he killed Thomas MAJKA; telling how he waited for him to pass; how he threw a stone which hit his victim on the head and afterwards jumped on his head until he had smashed the face into a jelly. He described how he then picked the body up and carried it down near the creek. This accounts for the blood which was found on his person in such large quantities. ROBINSKI, in his confession, says that PAVLIC was not with him and that he did not see him that night.
----<>----
YOUNG ROBBERS
 
    Chicago, Feb. 1 - A large number of petty robberies have recently been committed in the neighborhood of Wentworth avenue and Twenty ninth-street, detectives were put on the case and discovered that the culprits were a gang of boys. They had a cave under the sidewalk which contained a plentiful supply of revolvers, trashy literature, etc. Jimmie DYNES, who was in charge of the den, was arrested.
----<>----
ICE PASSING ST. LOUIS
 
    St. Louis, Feb. 1 - About 10:30 o'clock last night the lower end of the ice gorge, five miles below the city, gave way, and since then the ice has been flowing out in a continuous stream. No further damage has been reported. Ice has been coming down from above in a great stream, but it flows harmlessly through the harbor.
----<>----
DIED
 
RYAN - February 1, 1888, at 55 Hand street, William D. RYAN.  -Notice of funeral hereafter.
 
McKOEN - In this city on the evening of January 31st, 1888, Francis William, son of Frank and Jane McKOEN, at the family residence, 362 State street, aged 10 years.
-Funeral services at 8 o'clock Thursday morning at the Cathedral.
----<>----
ITEMS IN BRIEF
 
--There be 29 days in this month.
--February comes in mildly enough.
--A very interesting meeting of the Photographic Section of the Academy of Science was held last evening.
 
--Rochester trotters, St. Jacob and Gypsy, are entered for the races at Hamilton. They leave the city Friday night.
 
--Mrs. K. E. SMYTHE'S pupils will give a recital to-morrow evening at her studio. Mrs. Frank VICK and Miss May BUMAN will take part.
 
--A reception was given last night at Wisner's Hall by the Golden Star Progressive Euchre Club. After dancing supper was enjoyed at Worden's.
 
--Vick's Magazine for February is a rare treat for all lovers of horticulture. Spring will soon be here and this excellent magazine anticipates it with many interesting and instructive articles.
 
--On the 15th of next month the Internal Revenue office in this city will be removed from the present rooms in the first floor of Power's Block to the store next to the Fitzhugh street entrance to Powers hotel.
 
--A horse owned by Norris BULL ran away on Lake avenue yesterday morning. The animal started at Phelps avenue and ran to Brown street, where it was caught, but not until the cutter had been badly damaged.
 
--Members of the Golden Rule Chapter spent an enjoyable evening last night at the residence of the worthy matron of the chapter, Mrs. Kate F. WARNER, 37 North Fitzhugh street. An excellent programme was carried out, and afterward a good supper was served.
 
--The Yacht club held a meeting last evening in its rooms on West Main street. Captain George GOULDING instructed a large class in seamanship, teaching them a large number of useful knots, splices, etc. The club adjourned to meet again next Monday evening, when it is expected Commodore NEWELL will be present.
 
--When the spring time comes, when our fine new blocks shall be occupied, new public buildings in a fair way toward completion, proposed ground floor theater in process of erection, the Chamber of Commerce with a membership of 500, and all nature in harmony with the manifold enterprises of the hour, Rochesterians will have every reason to be supremely happy.
 
--The Rochester Woman's Christian Temperance Union held a special business meeting yesterday afternoon, in its rooms, East Main street and sent a message of greeting to the semi-annual meeting of the Wyoming County W. C. T. U., which convenes this week. Another special meeting will be held on Tuesday afternoon of next week to make arrangements for a donation and general reception, February 22nd.
----<>----
FOUND DEAD BY HER HUSBAND
 
Mrs. Job BUCKMAN died very suddenly yesterday afternoon at her residence in Greece. Mr. BUCKMAN was in the city on business at the time, and when he returned home found her dead on the bed. Dr. HILLMAN, who was called, expressed opinion that death was due to paralysis of the heart. Coroner SHARPE has been notified. Mrs. BUCKMAN was about 50 years of age, and beside her husband leaves three children.
----<>----
PERSONAL
 
--Lawrence J. TILDEN, one of Rochester's energetic young business men, was married yesterday, by the Rev. J. E. BAKER, to Miss Minnie A. WALSH, at the residence of the bride's parents, 184 West Main street. A handsome reception followed. The happy couple went East on their wedding tour.
 
--Rev. J. F. HOGAN, formerly of Rochester, has recently been appointed pastor of the Catholic church at Centerville, Dakota Territory. Father HOGAN's many friends will be pleased to hear of his promotion.
 
--Married, yesterday afternoon at the Bishop's residence, by the Rev. James E. HARTLEY, P. H. DOLAN of Elizabeth, N. J., and Miss Ona V. GASKELL. Mr. DOLAN is a popular young railroad contractor, having made many friends in and about Rochester, while the bride is an accomplished and popular young lady of this city. The happy couple left this morning on the flyer for an extended trip through the east, visiting the principal cities, including the home of the groom's mother at Elizabeth, N. J., after which they will return here, making Rochester their future home.
----<>----
COURT NOTES
 
--The will of John JENKINSON disposing of an estate amounting to about $32,000 was admitted to probate in the Surrogate's Court yesterday. An annuity of $1,200 and the use of the family residence is given to the wife. The remainder of the income of the estate is to be divided equally among the testator's three children, Mrs. Ann Elizabeth ALLEN, Mrs. Mary Louise HICKS and William Howell JENKINSON. At the death of the wife the estate is to be divided equally among the children.
 
--The will of Margaretta HOFFMAN was admitted to probate yesterday.
 
--P. McINTYRE made a motion yesterday before Judge ANGLE for the discharge from custody of George BENNETT, who was convicted of petit larceny in the Police Court and sentenced to six months imprisonment in the penitentiary and fined in addition $50 with the alternative of the same number of days imprisonment. Judge ANGLE took the papers.
 
--This afternoon Judge MACOMBER will hear the argument on the appeal from the report of the referee in the matter of the widening of Hand street.
----<>----
DIES FROM HIS INJURIES
    Frank McKEON, aged 11 years, living with his parents at 362 State street, received injuries yesterday afternoon, from which he died at 9 o'clock last night. It seems that he was playing in the snow banks on State street, near Factory, with several other children, when he was knocked down by a farmer's team drawing two hay racks. The sleighs passed over his body. He was picked up and taken home, where Drs. J. J. A. BURKE and E. P. BURKE attended him, but all efforts to save his life were fruitless. The farmer drove rapidly away after running over McKEON, and his name could not be ascertained.
----<>----
POLICE COURT CASES
 
--Harvey WEBER and William GUNN, two boys who stole a pair of rubber boots from Beck & Son's store, were sent to the State Industrial school.
 
--Mary LYONS, Drunk and disorderly, was paroled during good behavior.
 
--George MURPHY was arrested last night on the charge of stealing a watch from John FELBY.
----<>----
ARREST OF A STRIKER
    Timothy SULLIVAN was arrested this afternoon on the charge of assaulting William HAHN. The prisoner is one of the striking shoe makers and, it is alleged, assaulted HAHN last night because the latter is working in one of the shoe-shops. SULLIVAN was arrested on St. Joseph street, near Clifford. The police are still looking for the men who committed the assault on St. Paul street this morning.
----<>----
LOCAL NEWS
 
The Deacons Murder Trial
Testimony Taken for the Prosecution this Afternoon
    When court reconvened for the DEACONS murder trial this afternoon there was a large number of spectators present, including many ladies. Alonzo A. STONE was recalled and testified: When I returned from work I noticed the dinner dishes unwashed in the sink. The week's washing was in the kitchen. The baby carriage was not over the trap door, which was its usual position. There was a carpet in the center of the kitchen floor.
    When cross-examined by Mr. DAVIS, witness said: "I am twenty-nine years old and born in Rochester; have always lived here. I am a tinsmith; have been for eight years. I was married four years ago. When the homicide occurred I had lived on Haywood avenue one year. Before that I lived on George street. I never moved but once. My wife was twenty-one at the time of our marriage. At the time I was employed by Mr. JONES; had worked for him about two years. I had known Mr. JONES all my life. I went to work at Mr. HAYWARD'S the Monday before the homicide. Mr. JONES was at work there. He lives on Meigs street. I had known Mrs. JONES about six years. Our families visited and were quite intimate. On the morning of August 15th I left the house about five minutes of seven. My day's work commenced at 7 o'clock. It was about five minutes walk west to Mr. HAYWARD'S house. My. wife and son were at the house. She was eating her breakfast I think; do not remember what the conversation was. At the coroner's inquest I believe I testified that my wife spoke at noon about going down city. There was no such conversation in the morning. I left HAYWARD'S to go home at noon. I think I left home about ten minutes to 1. It might have been later. I saw my wife when I went home; she was getting dinner. My boy was there. I said hello. She said 'I am late with my dinner.' I think I said 'all right' or something to that effect. I made no complaint that dinner was late. She might have said something about its being wash day. The dinner was ready at half-past twelve. I heard the whistle blow. I did not know what whistle it was. I think I was about twenty minutes eating. My wife said she was going to the city to get the boy a pair of shoes. After that we might have had a little conversation. I do not remember what it was. When I left there were some carpenters working on another house in the rear of mine. They were eating their dinner when I reached home. Mr. JONES and I were working together most of the afternoon. I don't think we were out of each other's presence more than ten minutes at a time. No carpenters were working under me. They were not with me all the time. I quit work at 6 o'clock. I did not see any persons about the house when I reached home. I entered the back door which opens into the kitchen; met my little boy coming from the next lot and he said 'Mamma has gone and left me.' I said ' I guess not.' I went into the house; discovered nothing unusual; hung up my coat, washed my hands; went into the dining-room, then to the parlor, to see if my wife was there; went into the bedroom, and then up stairs, but found no traces; I came down and went into the kitchen; the carriage was not over the trap door; nothing else was disturbed. The trap door is on the east side leading into the cellar. I took the tubs and was going to put them away and start a fire. When I placed them in the cellar I saw the form of my wife. From the stairway I could see where she lay. I did not at first know it was she, but I recognized her before I reached the body. This was after six o'clock. She lay upon the left side with her head away from me and left arm extended above. I did not testify at the coroner's inquest that she lay on her back. I could see her distinctly without ant light. I went over and said 'Ida'; did not know she was dead before I spoke. After taking her hand and finding it cold I went up stairs, out doors and over to McKEE'S. I told him my wife was dead. Before going over there I do not think I went out and emptied anything out of a pail; I do not remember doing anything of the kind. McKEE said, 'My God,' when I told him. He lives on Garson avenue. We went back to my home and down cellar. He said, 'Lon, I pity you.' I asked him to go for the coroner and he left me alone. When I felt of my wife's hand; it was entirely cold. Two strangers, men, came to the house; do not believe I had any conversation with them. Dr. BUELL came and went down cellar. He examined my wife in my presence; he made an extended examination; think the two strangers were present, and officers ZIMMERMAN and CUMMINGS I went down cellar with them. CUMMINGS asked who the woman was and I said, my wife. He said the captain wanted to see me. I told him all right, but I did not want to be handcuffed. I told CUMMINGS that I last saw my wife at 6 o'clock. I was taken to the station. I was locked up until the next morning. My clothing was examined. In the morning I was sent to the jail and discharged Friday morning at 11 o'clock by the Court. When I left home at noon my wife's hair was put up. I cannot remember exactly how she was dressed.
    Reuben J. SMITH was called as the next witness; identified plans he had made of the Stone house. He gave the dimensions of the kitchen.
----<>----

___

GjS